Home › Forums › Why Don’t Students Like School? By Daniel T. Willingham › Chapter 3 › What makes a good teacher? › What Makes a Good Teacher?
February 26, 2018 at 1:29 pm #325
I think that Willingham makes many characteristics that stand out for teachers. One of the characteristics that I did like that he talked about was being able to be approachable. I think that there is a fine line between being too approachable where students walk all over you and being unapproachable, where students are less likely to participate and trust you in the class. I do not think that all teachers need to be storytellers. I think that teachers should be interactive and caring but I think that being a storyteller is not the number one characteristic because it is not the only way that students are learning. Stories may not work for every child, so without other characteristics, this characteristic is not as meaningful.February 28, 2018 at 12:20 pm #333
Willingham states that a good teacher has a certain style about them, while simultaneously having a knack for getting students to think through meaning and application. He then points out that what it really boils down to though is that the teacher seems like a good person in some way or another, and that they organize the class effectively. I think that both of these statements are very true. All of my favorite teachers have been the ones that I felt I had some level of a bond with. My high school geometry teacher was not a great teacher of the subject, but he was one of my favorite high school teachers because he had a big personality. I think that in showing students your true personality, you become more interesting to the students. This interest in you as a teacher can facilitate more student motivation to learn from you. Organization is also a huge factor for all types of students. Type A students will be annoyed if you aren’t as organized as they are, and Type B students need the structure and organization to guide them.
I think the concept of story telling as a means to teach is very interesting, but kind of ideological in many senses. It could work effectively with younger children in a handful of subjects, but I didn’t quite gather the application to upper level algebra or sciences from reading the chapter. It certainly has a place in education as a tool, but I don’t think it is as key as Willingham seems to think it is.March 2, 2018 at 8:40 am #343
I don’t necessarily agree with Willingham that teachers need to be approachable, I would argue they need to be authentic. This doesn’t necessarily mean you live your personal life as an open book to your students, but you have to show students you are human, do “normal” people things, and make mistakes too. Trying to maintain a dictator divide between teacher and student creates a barrier. You have to meet them at their level, but not make them feel ashamed that they are at that level.
I agree organization is a key component to good teaching. Structure, consistency, routine, and predictability are necessary. It helps students feel comfortable, know what to expect, and hopefully curb anxiety and fear. School becomes a safe place, because they know and understand the expectation.
I think the final thing a good teacher needs is nurturing. I don’t mean motherly kindergarten teachers who swoop in like a mother bird to protect her babies. I mean teachers who express encouragement into their students in a way that makes them believe they can achieve anything. If you have ever seen “Stand & Deliver,” Jaime Escalante does this. My AP US history teacher in high school did this too. I don’t know how to describe it and I don’t know if you can “teach” it to others. It is something special they had that worked. I think it becomes an element that “good” teacher can be made, but there are some that are just “born.”March 2, 2018 at 8:40 pm #371
Willingham says that a good teacher is both approachable and organized. For the most part I agree with both of these qualities. The majority of teachers that I thought were the “best” did have both of these. But, I’ve also had a few teachers that I was terrified of when in their class, but this was still very effective for me. They were more “strict” and less approachable, but they were still amazing teachers. Both typically yielded classes with very high test scores, and I came out of both feeling like I learned a lot. In terms of organization, I think that quality is a crucial one. A teacher and their classroom need to have both structure and consistency. This will help learners get into a “rhythm” and make the classroom environment more comfortable.March 4, 2018 at 5:12 pm #379
What other qualities do good teachers possess? I like Jared’s word of “nurturing” because I do think we learn from those we feel care about our learning. When I’m learning, if I feel the teacher does not care about my acquisition of the knowledge/skills, I’m super disengaged. I would add that knowledge is important although Courtney dispelled that a bit with her geometry teacher example. I am drawn to people who are very knowledgeable about things I want to learn about.March 19, 2018 at 1:04 am #421
I agree with Willingham. My previous professors who I consider my favorites were all people who I could connect with, who showed that “nurturing” aspect as Jared mentioned. They kept content the most authentic, they were authentic with their students, and offered uniques styles to teach. I remember the most content from their classes, and I find myself to resting to back to their teachings to help me with things, even outside of school.March 19, 2018 at 12:18 pm #428
I definitely agree with the characteristics that Willingham uses to describe a good teacher. Whenever I have had a personal connection with a teacher, I feel more engaged in the classroom. Also, if I am struggling in a class, I am more likely to seek help from a teacher that I feel connected to compared to one that comes off as more distant.
My Honors Chemistry teacher from my sophomore year of high school fits my ideal of a good teacher to a tee. She was extremely organized, which I really appreciated. The content of her class was definitely challenging, but she found ways to keep us engaged. I will never forget the way she helped us learn how to balance chemical reactions. We would give the elements names and pretend that they were dating and broke up with each other and then started dating someone else. It was the most random thing, but I think making a story out of it helped me understand why certain elements go together. I struggled a lot in this class, but because I knew that my teacher was truly invested in giving me the best education possible, I felt comfortable enough to reach out when I was having a hard time. She taught me how to advocate for myself when I need help and that regardless of where you start (for me that was getting a 56 on my 1st test), it is possible to be successful.
I agree with Jill in that storytelling doesn’t work for everyone. I think for younger students, it is a great tool, but it isn’t always applicable in high school or college settings. I think it is important to use a variety of methods when teaching so you can cater to all of your students needs and learning styles.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.